Discussions and Questions - Tata Tata
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
Comet has its own market but I don't see it competing with the Tiago EV seriously. People trust Tata more in India, they have a much stronger brand.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
The Comet can definitely compete, I think. The Tiago is just an electrified version of a regular car, whereas the S1 offers something really different. The Comet's small size is a big plus for city dwellers.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
I've driven them both and I'd say they are for different buyers. The Comet is perfect if you want a zippy little urban runabout and the Tiago feels more like a 'real' car. Both have room in the market.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
What’s lacking is the fast charging that the Tiago EV has. The result is that it severely limits its practicality for anything beyond short city trips.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
For me MG’s after sales service is still a question mark. I have more confidence in long term ownership thanks to Tata’s much larger network.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
In fact, it's the Comet's secret weapon: its unique design. The more conventional Tiago doesn’t turn heads and get people talking, whereas this one does. It could compete on that free marketing.
Can the MG Comet find a place in the market among players like Tata Tiago EV?
07 January 2025 08:04
India is a price king, and Comet is overpriced for what it offers. You get much more car for your money with the Tiago EV.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
Absolutely! This is peak Indian jugaad - practical, affordable and does the job. That’s Indian engineering at its best.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
Not really. It's just a cheap design. The real Indian engineering should be more forward looking and innovative.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
That's significant because it solves a problem that's uniquely Indian. Its looks aren't what makes it culturally important, but that.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
I'd say economically more than culturally. It's not meant to represent Indian culture, it's meant to be affordable.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
Now, yeah, it’s become part of the urban landscape, it’s culturally significant even if it wasn’t designed to be.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
Indian engineers adapt global ideas to local needs, as shown by the Magic IRIS. In itself that's culturally significant.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
No, it's just a box on wheels. That was nothing culturally significant. Our designs should aim higher.
Is the Tata Magic IRIS culturally significant in terms of Indian automotive engineering?
06 January 2025 12:26
This is important in terms of how India thinks differently from the West in terms of mass mobility. That's a cultural statement.
Can the Tata Magic IRIS be a practical solution to last mile connectivity in Indian cities?
06 January 2025 12:26
Absolutely! The Magic IRIS is ideal for narrow lanes that bigger vehicles can't travel down. For places with bad public transport, it’s a game changer.
Can the Tata Magic IRIS be a practical solution to last mile connectivity in Indian cities?
06 January 2025 12:26
It's just a glorified auto rickshaw, no way. The fact is we need proper buses and proper metro systems, not these band aid solutions.
Can the Tata Magic IRIS be a practical solution to last mile connectivity in Indian cities?
06 January 2025 12:26
It's a mixed bag. It’s great for rural areas, but cities will have to deal with more traffic chaos. We don't need more vehicles; we need better urban planning.
Can the Tata Magic IRIS be a practical solution to last mile connectivity in Indian cities?
06 January 2025 12:26
I am a daily commuter and it is super convenient. Cabs are cheaper than it and autos are more comfortable. Perfect for short trips.
Can the Tata Magic IRIS be a practical solution to last mile connectivity in Indian cities?
06 January 2025 12:26
That’s the concerning part: safety. But it feels flimsy compared with proper cars. Instead, we should be looking at safer alternatives.
Ask a Question