So I think it’s kind of dependent on what you are looking for. If you're after a modern scrambler that looks the part then a new retro scrambler is the way to go. The Trials 500 is the bike if you want the full vintage experience, quirks and all.

Honestly, either way works. The scrambler look is the gift that keeps on giving, and the Trials 500 gives you a head start on this look, but a standard Bullet is a blank canvas. That all depends on your vision and on your budget.

I don’t think people care enough about whether it’s ‘authentic’ or not. That’s fine, it’s a modern interpretation of a classic style. Everything doesn’t have to be a perfect replica.

If you're being real, most people buying this bike aren't hardcore off roaders. It's exactly what it is: a cool looking bike that can take the odd bit of rough stuff on the weekend. Not all off road bikes have to be capable of conquering the Dakar Rally.

I'd say it's overpriced for what it is, but it's not as if it's not worth it to the right buyer. Motorcycles are emotional purchases and if the Trials 500 does speak to you it is worth the premium.