Tata has just electrified its Punch micro-SUV as it gave birth to its first ‘pure’ EV. The prices for the recently launched Tata Punch EV go up to Rs 15.49 lakh (ex-showroom), which is the exact same price as the top-spec diesel Nexon sub-4m SUV. So naturally, there is bound to be some cross-shopping between the two and we are here to make your decision easier.
The electric vehicle (EV) revolution is well underway, and Tata Motors is at the forefront with its innovative lineup. Two notable contenders in the Tata EV portfolio are the Punch EV and the Nexon EV. The size difference between the Punch EV and Nexon is obvious. The latter has always been the elder, bigger sibling. As a result, the Nexon will offer you more room inside, thanks to a longer footprint and width. Even the headroom is slightly more in the Nexon, although they are on par in terms of overall boot space. That’s thanks to the Punch EV’s dual storage compartments as it gets a frunk, courtesy its dedicated EV platform.
1. Design and Exterior: Starting with aesthetics, both the Tata Punch EV and Nexon EV showcase Tata's commitment to contemporary design. On the other hand, the Nexon EV, being a larger SUV, combines sophistication with a commanding road presence.
2. Interior Comfort and Space: Stepping inside, the interior of both models reflects Tata's dedication to providing comfort and cutting-edge features. The Punch EV, despite its compact size, boasts a thoughtfully designed cabin that maximizes space and functionality.
3. Performance and Range: Under the hood, the Punch EV and Nexon EV pack electric powertrains designed for optimal performance and efficiency. The Punch EV, being a smaller vehicle, might have a slightly more nimble feel on the road, making it well-suited for urban environments.
4. Technological Features: Tata Motors has been incorporating advanced technology into its vehicles, and the Punch EV and Nexon EV are no exceptions.
5. Charging Infrastructure and Battery Technology: Charging infrastructure is a crucial aspect of EV ownership, and Tata Motors has been working to address this concern. Both the Punch EV and Nexon EV are likely to support fast-charging capabilities, allowing users to recharge their vehicles quickly. ?
This is where the biggest disparity between the two comes in. The Punch EV is a pure electric vehicle with a 35kWh battery pack and a claimed range of 421km. On the other hand, the top-spec Nexon costing Rs 15.49 lakh comes with a 1.5-litre diesel paired with a 6-speed AMT.
While the horsepower figures are very close to each other, their torque figures have a significant difference of 70Nm. Despite this, the Punch EV will be the quicker car (not yet tested), thanks to the instant power delivery from its electric powertrain.
6. Price and Cost of Ownership: The cost of ownership is a significant consideration for potential EV buyers. While the Punch EV is expected to be more budget-friendly, the Nexon EV's larger size and enhanced features may come with a higher price tag. Potential buyers will need to weigh these factors based on their individual preferences and requirements.
7. Market Impact and Sustainability: Before giving a verdict, we should note that the top-spec Fearless + S variant of the Nexon can also be had with a 1.2-litre turbo-petrol engine with 7-speed DCT. The prices for the top-spec turbo-petrol variant is priced at Rs 14.69 lakh (ex-showroom).
8. Conclusion: So if you opt for the top-spec turbo-petrol Nexon, you’ll be straight up saving Rs 80,000. But then again, the running cost of the Punch EV and Nexon will be vastly different in the long run. Because, nothing beats the running cost of an EV, especially if it is charged at home for the most part. In the ever-evolving landscape of electric vehicles, Tata Motors has positioned itself as a key player with the Punch EV and Nexon EV. While the Punch EV caters to those seeking a compact and adventurous electric SUV, the Nexon EV offers a more substantial option with enhanced features.
Both, the top-spec Nexon and Punch EV, are almost matched on the features front. There is some back and forth between the two, like the Nexon packing a better 9-speaker JBL sound system and rear AC vents. But the Punch EV gets the Arcade.EV application suite, which allows you to download various apps including Hotstar, for you to watch while charging the car. But moving beyond the powertrain, choosing between the two boils down to your wants and needs. If you will find yourself using the rear seats more often than not, you should pick the Nexon. It’s bigger, offers the same set of features (if not more), and has multiple powertrain options as well.