What are the long term costs as well as environmental impact of Ashok Leyland Dost CNG LS vs electric?
As environmental sustainability is gaining more attention and electric vehicles are becoming more popular, many small business owners are considering between CNG and electric mini trucks. The Ashok Leyland Dost CNG LS has been a popular vehicle in the past due to its relatively low emissions compared to diesel vehicles as they are entering the market with electric alternatives. The debates this has sparked about long term costs – initial purchase price, fuel/charging costs, maintenance, and government incentives – have been heated. Then there is the environmental impact question: CNG is cleaner than diesel, but electric vehicles can promise zero emissions (at least at the point of use). Nevertheless, the environmental comparison must take into account the source of electricity and battery production as well. CNG stations are also more common than EV charging points in many areas, which is another key point. Therefore, financially and environmentally which one makes more sense in the long run? In this article, we will look at the pros and cons of Dost CNG LS vs its electric counterparts.
I did the math, and the Dost CNG LS still wins for me. It is cheaper in terms of initial cost and the CNG infrastructure is already there. On paper, electric sounds good, but we are not there yet in terms of practicality.
My next vehicle, I’m even thinking about switching to electric. Although the Dost CNG LS has a low running cost, electric promises to be even lower in the long run. And the environmental benefits are tough to ignore.
Costs are only one half of the story – consider operational flexibility. I can refuel in minutes with the Dost CNG LS. And electric vehicles still can't come close to that, which is key for my business that runs a long time.
CNG is a good stepping stone but the future is electric. Now the Dost CNG LS is working great but I already have plans to switch to electric in the next 3-5 years when the technology and infrastructure in place would allow me to do so.
Electric is all the rage, but let’s face it, in most of India, the electricity is still coming from coal. At least I know I am using a cleaner fuel with the Dost CNG LS. It's not perfect, but it's a practical solution for the time being.
I have researched this a lot, and I still believe Dost CNG LS is a better option at present. People think that the total lifecycle emissions (including battery production for EVs) are clear cut. CNG is a good compromise.
For now, I’m staying with my Dost CNG LS, but I’m keeping an eye out for electric options. When fast charging stations become as common as CNG stations will be the tipping point for me.
From an environmental point of view, I feel much happier with my Dost CNG LS than with my old diesel vehicle. The idea of going fully electric is appealing though. I am just waiting for the right electric model that matches my business needs.
The vehicle is only part of the equation. Right now, the Dost CNG LS fits perfectly into the existing infrastructure. Electric sounds good, but it is a complete change in how we think about refueling and vehicle range.
I feel that people are underrating Dost CNG LS in this debate. It is a proven technology – much cleaner than diesel. Electric is the future, and CNG is an excellent bridge technology that is available and effective today.
Comment
Discussions and Questions What Are The Long Term Costs As Well As Environmental Impact Of Ashok Leyland Dost Cng Ls Vs Electric
Ask a Question