Was the Mahindra Naya Commander the most underrated Indian car in its time?
The Mahindra Naya Commander was unique among Indian vehicles, manufactured from 2005 to 2010. It was unique for the time, offering a combination of 9 seater, 4x4 robustness and a boxy design. These attributes notwithstanding, it never became a popular item and was discontinued. Looking back some automotive enthusiasts claim the Naya Commander was unfairly ignored and failed to receive the recognition it deserved during its production life. The vehicle was ahead of its time with its versatility, practicality and off road prowess, they claim, and the vehicle deserved more recognition than it got. Some, though, argue that its subpar performance was the result of deliberate poor design, inadequacies in performance, or insufficient market exposure.
Mahindra Naya Commander
Ad
Join the Discussion
Add a useful reply, help other readers, and earn points for a quality contribution.
Comments (9)
@angad-kumaover 1 year ago
Mahindra had potential, but he didn’t develop it enough. A few more iterations could've been great.
@naresh-kumover 1 year ago
Underrated? No way. It deserved to be rated mediocre at best, and that’s exactly what it was.
@bhramita-rover 1 year ago
It was ahead of its time. These days, everyone wants a boxy SUV with lots of room.
@md-shafi-iover 1 year ago
Now, it might’ve been a gas guzzler in terms of practicality, but it was a gas guzzler. That in itself made it hard to justify.
@rahul-sahuover 1 year ago
Underrated for sure. Had it been given more time, it could’ve been India’s answer to the Land Rover Defender.
@gazal-singover 1 year ago
I will give it that, it was unique. However, to be unique isn't always a good thing.
@sakshi-gupover 1 year ago
Definitely underrated. It was essentially the Indian market's Hummer mini.
@abhay-singover 1 year ago
Underrated? More like overpriced. This was too expensive for what it was offering.
Ad
Start a Discussion & Win!
Ask questions, share insights, or start conversations about cars. Win ₹1,000 every week for engaging discussions.
Weekly Prize: ₹1,000
Most Popular Cars
Based on Cars Popular on Maxabout
3 models available
Available Models
3 models
Currently available for purchase

