Does the Aston Martin Vantage (2018) earn the premium over its rivals?

Absolutely worth it. But the Vantage is a head turner like no other in the class. True, a 911 is more useful, but you will look like every other dentist on the road. Each time that you drive the Aston, it stands out and makes you feel special.

I would say it doesn’t deserve the premium. The AMG engine, while powerful, lacks the character of Aston's old V8s. For the same money you could pick up a 911 GT3, which is a far better driver’s car and will retain its value better.

It's a mixed bag. The Vantage is gorgeous and sounds great, but the interior quality and infotainment system are behind the German competition. Pure driving thrills, however, are to be found elsewhere. If nothing else, the Aston makes a statement, however.

From an owner’s perspective, 100% worth it! It is a raw and engaging driving experience that modern cars so rarely are. Moreover, exclusivity is such a huge factor here – you don't see these all over the place like you do with Porsches.

I would say it depends on what you want I suppose. This is not the ultimate track weapon or daily driver, though. However, if you want a car that puts the James Bond in you every time you take a seat behind the wheel, then nothing else is going to do the trick.

Its not worth it in my opinion. Been playing for three years and have so far been molested by many CEOS. The ownership is a headache thanks to the reliability issues and high maintenance costs. You it's more the badge you are paying for.

If that appeals to you and you appreciate the Aston Martin character, it is worth it. The Vantage is deliberately not the fastest or most practical – it’s about style, presence and, as much as you can come by it in a new car, that special feeling of driving a real British sports car.

In my opinion, the roof is definitely worth it for the right buyer. While the Vantage is a more exotic experience than a 911, the reliability of the Vantage is better than Italian alternatives. Those who want something special, without the constant headaches, will be able to find some good value here.

It's a tough call. Overall, the Vantage is surely beautiful and provides a unique level of driving experience. Objectively speaking, however, cars such as the 911, or even the Corvette C8, will outpace the speed of the Z4M and cost less money too. It all boils down to how much you respect the Aston Martin brand and aesthetics.

I use my Vantage daily and it’s quite good. It's decently visible, practical (more than you think), and the suspension is firm without feeling punishing. It also makes every commute a special ride.

Not as a primary daily. Simple errands are a chore because of the limited storage space, terrible rearward visibility, and attention it draws. If you keep it as a weekend toy you will enjoy it much more.

The impracticalities are actually quite good as a daily if you can live with them. It’s a comfortable car for long drives, the infotainment is okay and it’s not as wide as supercars thus it’s a bit easier to park.

I’ve had mine daily driven for a year and it’s been great. Yes, yes, a 911 is terribly practical, but a 911 is a hell of a lot more usable than most folks assume. It’s surprisingly spacious in the boot and rides compliantly to be a daily driver.

I would not recommend it as someone who tried to drive Vantage daily. It becomes old very fast when all you’re staring at is keeping the front splitter from scraping and the attention it draws.

It’s a good daily, but not for an ideal one. The biggest problems for me are the lack of visibility and the constant paranoia of parking lot door dings. However, if you can overcome that, it becomes a great daily driver.

I love my daily and use it. It has its quirks, but the car makes each drive an event. However, you will have to be prepared for frequent fuel stops and many long conversations with strangers at gas stations.