Against what electric alternatives is the Ashok Leyland Dost CNG LE competing in urban deliveries?
Commercial vehicles are usually versatile beyond their stock configuration, as many businesses customize them to fit their own needs. The Dost CNG LE from Ashok Leyland is a compact vehicle with an efficient powertrain that could potentially be used as a base for specialized applications. The possibilities seem diverse ranging from mobile food trucks to compact waste management vehicles. But, there are its own challenges and safety considerations in modifying CNG vehicles. This brings up the question of whether the Dost CNG LE can be customized, and whether Ashok Leyland supports or encourages such modifications. Could this vehicle's adaptability make new market segments accessible to it?
CNG is clearly the better option for now. The charging infrastructure isn’t there yet and the cars remain too expensive. The Dost CNG LE is a best of both worlds type of solution; it gives you lower emissions and it gives you practical usability.
I disagree. Urban deliveries are electric, that is the way forward. The Dost CNG LE is simply postponing the day when it will have to make way for the inevitable. You are planning for zero emission zones in cities, and CNG is not going to make it in the long run.
Both have their place. For longer routes, where range may be an issue for EVs, the Dost CNG LE is great; and short frequent urban deliveries are ideal for EVs.
For me, I’ve used both, and the Dost CNG LE is more reliable, for now. But the reality is that for the delivery business, charging electric vehicles is a real productivity killer with the downtime.
The comparison isn’t between the vehicles, but all of the ecosystem as well. For now, the Dost has an edge over electric alternatives as CNG has a more established infrastructure in many Indian cities.
Payload capacity is not forgotten. Batteries typically come at the cost of cargo space. This is not an issue with the Dost CNG LE, which is important for businesses that need to maximize each trip.
I believe we are not paying attention to the noise factor. Early morning or late night deliveries in residential areas are a lot quieter with electric vehicles. On that front, the Dost CNG LE can’t compete.
I’m an automotive enthusiast so I like both options. The Dost CNG LE demonstrates just how far we can take traditional powertrains while electric vehicles are beginning to usher in new technology in automotive technology.
Why not both? If smart businesses are going to use CNG vehicles, they will likely mix in electric vehicles for different types of deliveries and routes.
Absolutely! The diesel Dost has some creative mods, and the CNG version should be just as flexible. It is known as mobile workshops, refrigerated deliveries and you name it. It has a compact size which enables it to navigate the tight urban spaces.
I'm skeptical. Modifying CNG systems could be risky and they are more complex. Also, any major changes will void the warranty. Probably best to stay with the stock configuration.
Why not if the modifications are done professionally? The way is to work with the Ashok Leyland approved workshops. If there is enough demand, they might even offer some official mod kits.
I actually have used a modified Dost CNG LE for my mobile coffee business. It takes some careful planning as to where the CNG tank would go but this has been a great, eco friendly solution for me.
I think there is a potential, but I think Ashok Leyland needs to lead in this. They could really take off if they had a range of pre approved mods or an easily modifiable base model.
Weight distribution not to be forgotten. Modifications have to take into consideration vehicle’s payload capacity and the impact of additional weight on vehicle’s performance and safety, especially with CNG system.
I’m more interested in tech mods. Think about fitting your Dost CNG LE with the features where advanced telematics and autonomous delivery systems are concerned. It could be huge for some businesses.
Could it be converted into a mini passenger vehicle? It could be amazing eco friendly option for last mile connectivity in the smaller towns with some creative seating arrangements.
The Dost CNG LE is a good way to take steps towards greener transportation. It allows businesses to immediately take advantage of electric vehicle technology, without hanging around until technology matures.
I think it's just greenwashing. Despite being a fossil fuel, CNG is still a fossil fuel and methane leaks during production and transportation can negate any emissions advantages. We should be concentrating on the real zero emission solutions.
The bigger picture is all. Although not perfect, the Dost CNG LE is a lot cleaner than diesel. Even every little bit in this fight matters.
I can say that from someone who switched from a diesel vehicle to Dost CNG LE, the difference in emissions is quite a bit. It has an eco friendly angle and my customers appreciate that as well.
The question is about infrastructure. The Dost CNG LE is green only to the extent of the green CNG network it runs on. It will not be truly effective until we have more filling stations and cleaner methods of producing CNG.
We should not overlook noise pollution. The Dost CNG LE is a big plus for urban environments as it is significantly quieter than diesel alternatives.
I believe we are missing the opportunity to use biogas. Additionally, if it is possible to scale up biogas production, the Dost CNG LE could get even greener.
The Dost CNG LE is fine for the present circumstances, but we need to look ahead. In 10 years will electric vehicles be a reality and will my argument still be relevant?
Diversity in our approach to green transportation is the key. The Dost CNG LE is among the electric, hybrid and even hydrogen vehicles. Different solutions for different needs.
The switch from old, smoky diesel tempos to the Dost CNG LE would make a huge difference in air quality. And CNG does not produce that CO2, it’s not just CO2, it also does not produce particulate matter or some other nasty pollutants.
I am skeptical about the real impact in the real world. Yes, CNG is cleaner than diesel but in the increasing traffic, are we merely delaying the rate of pollution instead of actually improving the air quality?
The vehicles themselves aren’t the only thing; there is also congestion reduction. How efficient the Dost CNG LE runs means the less trips and less idling time could have a huge impact on air quality.
I drive in the city daily and I do see that areas with more CNG vehicles do seem to have clearer air. Again, this is anecdotal, but I feel that widespread adoption of the Dost CNG LE would make a big difference.
The whole lifecycle has to be considered. The problem with CNG is that if the production and transportation of CNG is not clean then we may just be moving the problem around rather than solving it.
After all, we must not forget the psychological impact. The more green vehicles such as the Dost CNG LE that can be seen on the road, the more it would lead to other companies and people making more eco friendly choices.
I believe that we are overlooking the possibility of improving CNG technology to make it more widely used. In the future, Ashok Leyland’s innovation on making the Dost even cleaner could have an even bigger impact on air quality.
The real question is whether CNG is the best use of resources. Would better air quality be achieved if we spent equal effort towards electrification or public transportation?
Since I am an automotive enthusiast, I’m really hyped about the Dost CNG LE. The emissions are not the only issue, but also forcing other manufacturers to improve the cleanliness of their vehicles.
Comment
Discussions and Questions Against What Electric Alternatives Is The Ashok Leyland Dost Cng Le Competing In Urban Deliveries
Ask a Question