When it comes to choosing your first luxury car, especially if you're looking for a diesel engine and higher ground clearance, the BMW X1 and Mercedes-Benz GLA stand out as strong contenders. Both models have undergone updates, with the third-generation BMW X1 going on sale last year and the second-generation Mercedes-Benz GLA receiving a refresh.
Design and Appearance
The BMW X1 and Mercedes-Benz GLA both have a substantial presence, with the BMW being slightly larger overall. However, neither is as large as a typical SUV like the Fortuner. The BMW X1's design is more traditional with upright pillars and a larger glasshouse giving it a classic SUV look. It features a large kidney grille and distinctive tail lights. The M Sport package adds sportier bumpers, but the standard 18-inch wheels might leave some desiring more.
On the other hand, the Mercedes-Benz GLA has a swoopy stance, giving it a crossover appearance. The top-spec AMG Line variant is particularly eye-catching with its 19-inch AMG wheels. The 2024 model year GLA can be identified by its new headlight and tail-light designs and a body-color matching apron on the bumper.
Interior and Comfort
Both the X1 and GLA offer luxurious interiors. The BMW X1's asymmetric dashboard and floating center console give it a modern look and the use of premium materials is evident throughout. The GLA has a more youthful vibe, with highlights like the turbine-like air-con vents. The updated software for the twin screens in the GLA makes it more user-friendly compared to BMW's system, which has a steeper learning curve.
In terms of seating both models provide comfortable front seats. The BMW X1's seats offer more support and even include a lumbar massage function. The X1 also has a slight edge in rear seat comfort with a recline function and the option to adjust the seat position. However, the GLA's lack of a rear center armrest is a notable omission.
Both SUVs offer ample room for tall passengers in the back, but neither is ideal for seating three adults side by side. In terms of luggage space, both models are flexible, with the option to fold the seats flat for additional cargo room.
Features and Technology
Both the X1 and GLA are well-equipped with features like LED headlights, dual-zone climate control, panoramic sunroofs, ambient lighting, wireless connectivity, and gesture-controlled tailgates. The GLA stands out with its 360-degree camera which adds an extra layer of convenience.
Safety features in both models include airbags, ESC, tire pressure monitoring, ISOFIX mounts, and some ADAS functions like auto emergency braking and blind spot warning. The BMW also offers lane departure warning providing an additional safety measure.
Performance and Handling
Both the X1 and GLA are based on front-wheel-drive platforms, with the GLA diesel now featuring all-wheel drive as standard. The GLA's 2-liter diesel engine outperforms the BMW's with 190hp and 400Nm compared to the X1's 150hp and 360Nm. This results in a more punchy mid-range and impressive acceleration for the GLA, with a 0-100kph time of 7.4 seconds.
The GLA handles well with good grip and steering feedback making it enjoyable to drive. However, its ride can feel firm, and the suspension can be noisy over rough surfaces. In contrast, the BMW X1 provides a more comfortable ride and better engine refinement. It's quick to accelerate in the city, but its performance on the highway is less impressive compared to the GLA.
Verdict
Choosing between the BMW X1 and Mercedes-Benz GLA depends on personal priorities. The X1 offers a more traditional SUV look and quieter engine but may not be as convincing on paper with its lower power output. The GLA, with its stronger performance and sportier handling, appeals more to those who value power and driving pleasure, despite its noisier engine and firmer ride.