The WagonR's relatively high seating position: Is a safety feature or is it a rollover risk?
The Maruti WagonR’s tall boy design gives you a higher seating position than most other hatchbacks in its class. Different groups of users and safety experts alike have praised and criticized this feature. Supporters say the added height means drivers have better visibility, allowing them to better maneuver through traffic and perhaps reducing the danger of accidents. It also makes ingress and egress easier, they claim, especially for older passengers or those with mobility issues. But critics note that the higher center of gravity also will raise the risk of rollovers, especially during sudden maneuvers or in accident scenarios. The debates have been around the fact that WagonR design prioritizes everyday convenience over safety in extreme situations. The question extends to the broader question of how different design philosophies in the automotive world make tradeoffs between different aspects of safety and usability.
In my WagonR I feel much safer. With the high seating I have a great view of the road, and I can see potential hazards easily. It's like driving a mini-SUV!
That's definitely a rollover risk. In sharp turns I have felt my WagonR lean uncomfortably. I don’t think the stability control is sufficient to override the high center of gravity.
I think it's a bit of both. Great visibility for daily driving, but I wouldn’t want to do any aggressive maneuvers in it. It's all about what you can do to drive within the car's limits.
With back problems, the high seating position is a godsend. It is very easy to get in and out of. While the potential risks are there, for me that daily convenience outweighs those risks.
I've never felt unsafe in my WagonR on highways. I don't think the rollover risk is exaggerated. How often do you really have to do sudden, extreme maneuvers anyway?
Until you have to take a U turn, this is great high seating. Then you truly start to feel how top heavy the car is. It's a trade off and I don't know if it's worth it.
It's mostly safety, I think. With our chaotic traffic in India being able to see over other cars is a huge advantage. You'll be fine as long as you just drive sensibly.
Comment
Discussions and Questions The Wagonrs Relatively High Seating Position Is A Safety Feature Or Is It A Rollover Risk
No answers found .