Does the Magnite’s 4 star GNCAP rating actually mean safety?
A big selling point for the Nissan Magnite was its 4-star global NCAP safety rating, which in a segment where safety generally comes last after features and pricing. The lab crash test results have led to conversation about how they relate to real world safety scenarios. There are some who believe the rating gives them peace of mind, and represents a well built structure, while others are skeptical if it really represents the car's ability to protect occupants in a variety of accident scenarios that prevail on Indian roads. It also discusses the relevance of active vs passive safety features and how the Magnite’s safety package fares against competitors with lower ratings but a wider safety feature quotient.
I have peace of mind with the 4 star rating. But it's not just about the stars, the Magnite's body structure did well in the crash tests too. In real accidents, that’s gotta count for something.
I'm skeptical. One thing is lab tests, and Indian roads are a whole other ballgame. A car with a lower GNCAP score, but with more airbags and advanced driver assists, I’d feel safer in.
Crash tests are a good baseline, but real world safety is about more than that. But the Magnite's higher ground clearance and good visibility are safety plusses not accounted for in the GNCAP score.
For me, I have been in a fender bender with my Magnite and it held up pretty well. The crumple zones worked and the cabin held together. I think the 4 star rating is legit.
I hate to knock the rating, but I wish Nissan would have had ESP standard across all variants and other active safety items. That would go a long way toward preventing accidents in the first place.
Well let’s be real, any car with 4 stars rating is going to be way safer than the average car on Indian roads. It's not perfect, but it's a massive step up in safety for budget car buyers.
I think these ratings are too important to people. Safety is just as important and just as hard to maintain as defensive driving. The Magnite's good, but not a force field.
Comment
Discussions and Questions Does The Magnites 4 Star Gncap Rating Actually Mean Safety
No answers found .