Tata Punch Creative AMT vs MG Astor Style vs Citroen C3 Live Comparison
Updated: 20, Jul, 2022 05:43 AM
Ex-Showroom Price
₹ 9,44,900
* Delhi. May vary.
POPULARITY
|
Ex-Showroom Price
₹ 10,81,800
* Delhi. May vary.
Discontinued
POPULARITY
|
Ex-Showroom Price
₹ 6,16,000
* Delhi. May vary.
POPULARITY
|
|
QUICK FACTS & INFORMATION | |||
| Car Variant | |||
| Tata Punch Creative AMT | MG Astor Style | Citroen C3 Live | |
| Latest Price in India | |||
| Tata Punch Creative AMT price is Rs 9.45 lakh (ex-showroom). | MG Astor Style price was INR 10.82 lakh before being discontinued. | Citroen C3 Live price is Rs 6.16 lakh (ex-showroom). | |
| Availability Status in India | |||
| Available | Discontinued | Available | |
| Car Type | |||
| SUV | SUV | SUV | |
| Fuel Type | |||
| Petrol | Petrol | Petrol | |
| Official Tagline | |||
| To Pack A Punch | India's First Car with AI Inside | Express Your Style | |
| ARAI Mileage (Certified) | |||
| 18.82 kmpl | 10-12 kmpl | 19.8 kmpl | |
| Colour Options | |||
| Orcus White, Daytona Grey, Tornado Blue, Atomic Orange, Meteor Bronze, Calypso Red, Tropical Mist | Spiced Orange, Aurora Silver, Glaze Red, Candy White, Starry Black | Polar White, Zesty Orange, Platinum Grey, Steel Grey | |
| Similar Cars | |||
| Maruti S-Presso, Renault Kwid, Maruti Ignis, Renault Kiger, Nissan Magnite, Datsun Redi-GO | Hyundai Creta, Kia Seltos, Renault Duster Skoda Kushaq, Volkswagen Taigun, Nissan Kicks | Hyundai Venue, Maruti Brezza, Mahindra XUV300, Tata Nexon, Kia Sonet, Nissan Magnite, Toyota Urban Cruiser | |
| Top Speed | |||
| 150 kmph | 164+ kmph | NA | |
ENGINE & TRANSMISSION | |||
| Engine cc (Displacement) | |||
| 1199 cc | 1498 cc | 1198 cc | |
| Gearbox Type | |||
| 5-Speed Automatic | Manual | Manual | |
| Number of Gears | |||
| 5 | 5-Speed Manual | 5-Speed Manual Transmission | |
| Maximum Power | |||
| 86 HP @ 6000 rpm | 110 HP @ 6000 rpm | 82 HP @ 5750 rpm | |
| Maximum Torque | |||
| 113 Nm @ 3300+/-100 rpm | 144 Nm @ 4400 rpm | 115 Nm @ 3750 rpm | |
| Engine Details | |||
| 1199cc, 1.2 Revotron, 3-Cylinder Petrol Engine | 1498cc, 1.5L VTi-Tech, 4-Cylinder Petrol Engine | 1198cc, 1.2L Puretech 82 (Naturally Aspirated), 3-Cylinder Petrol Engine | |
| Number of Cylinders | |||
| 3 | 4 | 3 | |
| Driving Modes | |||
| Eco and City | NA | NA | |
| Emission Norms | |||
| BS6-Compliant | BS6-Compliant | BS6-Compliant | |
Key Features of the Car | |||
| Steering | |||
| Steering Lock by Smart Key (ESCL Auto Lock) | NA | NA | |
| List of Features | |||
| Some of the key Tata Punch Creative AMT features include: ABS with EBD, Front Dual Airbags, ISOFIX, Engine Immobilizer through PEPS Key, Mechanical Child Safety Lock on Rear Doors, Front & Rear Wheel Arch Liners, Door Trim without Fabric Insert on Armrest, Instrument Cluster with 7" Partial Color TFT Display, City & Economy - Two Drive Modes, HVAC - Manual (Mechanical Actuation) Mode Selection, Electric Power Assisted Steering Collapsible, Steering Mounted Control, All Power Windows with One Touch Down Function (Driver Side), Push Start Stop, Front Fog & Cornering Lamp, Diamond Cut Alloy Wheels Black Color with Full Wheel Cap, Center Door Lock with PEPS Remote (5 Doors), Passive Keyless Entry, Cruise Control, Microphone, Tool Kit, Floating 7" Touchscreen Infotainment By Harman, Android Auto, Apple CarPlay, 4 Speakers, 2 Tweeters, Reverse Parking Camera, Projector Headlamps, Roof Rails, Rain Sensing Wipers, Fully Automatic Temperature Control, Rear Defogger, Puddle Lamps, Traction Pro. | Some of the key MG Astor Style features include: Dual Front Airbags, Electronic Stability Program, ABS + EBD + Brake Assist, Traction Control System, Active Cornering Brake Control, Hill Hold Control, Hill Descent Control, Emergency Stop Signal, Rear Parking Sensors, Security Alarm, Door Ajar Warning, Central Locking, Speed Sensing Auto Door Lock, Child Lock, Impact Sensing Door Unlock, Emergency Fuel Cutoff, ISOFIX Child Anchor, Intrusion Minimizing and Collapsible Steering Column, Rear Spoiler, Premium Fabric Seat Upholstery, Premium Soft Touch Dashboard, 8.9cm Coloured Multi Info Display, 25.7cm (10.1) HD Touchscreen Infotainment, Android Auto & Apple Carplay, 2 Speakers, 2 Tweeters, Steering Mounted Audio Controls, USB + FM + Bluetooth Music & Calling, Remote Keyless Entry with Foldable Key, Auto AC, PM 2.5 Filter, Electronic Power Steering with Mode Adjust (Normal, Urban, Dynamic), All Power Windows with Driver Window One Touch Auto Down. | Here is the list of key features of the Citroen C3 Live - Dual Front Airbags, Reverse Parking Sensors, Digital Cluster, Tripmeter, Distance to Empty, Gear Shift Indicator, Smartphone Storage - Rear Console, Smartphone Charger Wire Guide on Instrument Panel, Manual Air Conditioner with Heater, Intermittent Front Windscreen Wipers, Bag Support Hooks in Boot, Front Power Windows with One-Touch Auto Down, Rubic/Nimbus Seat Upholstery - Fabric (Bolster/Insert), Single Tone Black Interior, 'TESSERA' Full Wheel Cover, Matte Black Front Grill, Silver Painted Front Panel: Brand Emblems - Chevron. | |
COMFORT & CONVENIENCE | |||
| Bottle Holder | |||
| Anti-glare Mirrors | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Tilt Steering Wheel | |||
| NA | |||
| Front Passenger Seat Adjustement | |||
| Recliner Seats with Driver Seat Head Restraint (4 Way) | NA | NA | |
| Luggage Lamp | |||
| NA | |||
| HVAC Air Distribution Settings | |||
| HVAC - Manual (Mechanical Actuation) Mode Selection | NA | NA | |
| Variable Intermittent Wipers | |||
| Front Wiper with Wash System- Multi Speed (Low - High - Fixed Intermittent) | NA | Intermittent Front Windscreen Wipers | |
| Keyless Entry | |||
| Passive Keyless Entry | Remote Keyless Entry with Foldable Key | NA | |
| Rear Defogger | |||
| NA | |||
| Heat-reflecting windscreen | |||
| Windscreen Glass (Laminated Glass with Shadow Band with UV Reduction) | NA | NA | |
| Engine Start/Stop Button | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Rear Washer & Wiper | |||
| NA | |||
| Rain Sensing Wipers | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Luggage Net & Hook | |||
| Carry Bag Hooks in Console & Boot | NA | Bag Support Hooks in Boot (3 kg) | |
| Coat Hooks | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Grab Rail | |||
| Collapsible Grab Handles | NA | NA | |
| Steering Mounted Controls | |||
| Steering Wheel Switches without Instrument Cluster Control & Cruise Control | Steering Mounted Audio Controls | NA | |
| Air Conditioner | |||
| Fully Automated Temperature Control | Automatic AC | Manual Air Conditioner with Heater | |
| Power Steering | |||
| Electric Power Assisted Steering ( EPAS) Collapsible | Electronic Power Steering with Mode Adjust (Normal, Urban, Dynamic) | Electric Power Steering | |
| Cruise Control | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Power Windows | |||
| Front & Rear Power Windows with One-Shot Down Function (Driver Side) | All Power Windows with Driver Window One Touch Auto Down | Front Power Windows with One-Touch Auto Down | |
ACTIVE & PASSIVE SAFETY FEATURES | |||
| Impact Sensing Auto Door Unloock System | |||
| NA | |||
| Front Seatbelt Pre-Tensioner | |||
| Driver Seat Belt : 3 pt ELR with Retractor Pre-tensioners and Load Limiters | Driver & Co-Driver Seat Belt with Pretensioner & Load Limiter | NA | |
| Automatic Emergency Unlock | |||
| Auto Door Unlock Feature (After Key Removal from Ignition Barrel) | NA | NA | |
| Rear View Camera | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Seatbelt Reminder | |||
| Driver Seat Belt Reminder (SBR) (Buckle Based) | Front Driver & Co-Driver Seatbelt Reminder | Driver & Co-Driver Side | |
| Airbags | |||
| Dual Front Airbags | Dual Front Airbags | Front Driver and Passenger Airbags | |
| Front Seat Belts | |||
| Driver Seat Belt Buckel Switch (Belt Use Warning/Alarm) | 3 Point Seat Belts for All Passengers | NA | |
DIMENSIONS & WEIGHT | |||
| Overall Length | |||
| 3827 mm | 4323 mm | 3981 mm | |
| Overall Width | |||
| 1742 mm | 1809 mm | 1733 mm | |
| Overall Height | |||
| 1615 mm | 1650 mm | 1604 mm | |
| Wheelbase | |||
| 2445 mm | 2585 mm | 2540 mm | |
| Kerb Weight | |||
| 1035 kg | NA | 939 kg | |
| Ground Clearance | |||
| 190 mm | 180 mm | 180 mm | |
PERFORMANCE & MILEAGE | |||
| Approach Angle (degrees) | |||
| 20.3 degrees | NA | NA | |
| Departure Angle (degrees) | |||
| 37.6 degrees | NA | NA | |
| Ramp Breakover Angle (degrees) | |||
| 22.2 degrees | NA | NA | |
| Maximum wading depth | |||
| 370 mm | NA | NA | |
EXTERIOR FEATURES | |||
| Electrically Foldable ORVMs | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Electrically Adjustable ORVMs | |||
| NA | |||
| Mud Flaps | |||
| Provision for Front & Rear Mud Flaps | NA | NA | |
| Side Cladding | |||
| Wheel Arch & Door Claddings - As Moulded | Black Wheel & Side Cladding | NA | |
| Body Coloured Outside Mirrors | |||
| NA | |||
| Body Coloured Door Handles | |||
| Outside Door Handle with Chrome Highlights | NA | ||
| B Pillar Black Out Tape | |||
| Plastic Trim | NA | Sash Tape | |
| Front Bumper Spoiler | |||
| Front Bumper Energy Absorber | NA | NA | |
| Puddle Lights | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Body Coloured Bumpers | |||
| Cover for Tow Hook at Front Bumper | Rear Bumper with Chrome Accentuated Dual Exhaust Design | ||
| A-Pillar Glossy Black Finish | |||
| A Pillar with Black Tape | NA | Sash Tape | |
| C Pillar High Gloss Finish | |||
| Plastic Trim | NA | NA | |
| Roof Rails | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Tinted Glass | |||
| NA | NA | ||
BRAKES & SUSPENSION | |||
| Front Brakes | |||
| Disc | Disc | Disc | |
| Rear Brakes | |||
| Drum | Disc | Drum | |
| Front Suspension | |||
| Independent, Lower Wishbone, Mcpherson Strut with Coil Spring | MacPherson Strut | MacPherson Strut with Coil Spring | |
| Rear Suspension | |||
| Semi-Independent Twist Beam with Coil Spring and Shock Absorber | Torsion Beam | Rear Twist Beam with Coil Spring | |
INTERIOR FEATURES | |||
| Door Centre trim and door armrest | |||
| Door Trim Without Fabric Insert on Armrest | Premium Leather Layering on Dashboard, Door Trim, Door Armrest and Centre Console with Stitching Det | NA | |
| Glove Box Cooling | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Map Pockets | |||
| Magazine Pocket at Rear | NA | ||
| Child Seat Mounting Provisions | |||
| NA | |||
| Sunvisor with Ticket Holder | |||
| Sunvisors - Driver & Co-Driver with Vanity Mirror on Co-Driver Side | NA | NA | |
| lluminated Glovebox | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Leather Steering/Gear knob | |||
| NA | |||
INFOTAINMENT | |||
| Internet Connectivity Features | |||
| iRA Connected Car Technology | NA | NA | |
| Apple Car Play | |||
| NA | |||
| Android Auto | |||
| NA | |||
| Number of Speakers | |||
| 4 | 2 | NA | |
| Tweeters | |||
| 2 | 2 | NA | |
| AUX Compatibility | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| USB Compatibility | |||
| NA | |||
| Music System | |||
| Floating 7" Touchscreen Infotainment By Harman | 25.7cm (10.1) HD Touchscreen Infotainment | NA | |
CAPACITY | |||
| Number of Seating Rows | |||
| 2 Rows | 2 Rows | 2 Rows | |
| Number of Doors | |||
| 5 Doors | 5 Doors | 5 Doors | |
| Boot Space | |||
| 366 litres | 475 litres | 315 litres | |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | |||
| 37 litres | 48 litres | 30 litres | |
| Seating Capacity | |||
| 5 | 5 | 5 | |
BRAKING & TRACTION | |||
| Electronic Brake Distribution (EBD) | |||
| NA | |||
| Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) | |||
| NA | |||
| Traction Control | |||
| Traction Pro | NA | ||
LOCKS & SECURITY | |||
| Engine Immobilizer | |||
| Engine Immobilizer Through PEPS Key | |||
| Smart Key | |||
| Smart Key with Hidden Key for Emergencies | NA | NA | |
| Child-Protection Door Locks | |||
| Central Locking | |||
| Center Door Lock with PEPS Remote (5 Doors) | NA | ||
WHEELS & TYRES | |||
| Tubeless Tyres | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Full Wheelcaps | |||
| Black Color with Full Wheel Cap | 'TESSERA' Full Wheel Cover | ||
| Front Tyre | |||
| 195/60-R16 | 215/60-R16 | 195/65-R15 | |
| Rear Tyre | |||
| 195/60-R16 | 215/60-R16 | 195/65-R15 | |
| Wheels | |||
| R16 Diamond Cut Alloy Wheels | Steel Wheels | NA | |
| Spare Wheel | |||
| 185/70-R15 Steel Wheels | 215/60-R16 Steel Wheel | 165/80-R14 Steel Wheel | |
SEATS & UPHOLSTERY | |||
| Front Seat Back Pockets | |||
| Co-Driver Seat ( 2 Way, Full Fabric with RR Pocket) | NA | ||
| Rear Headrest (Adjustable) | |||
| NA | |||
| Fabric Upholstry | |||
| Premium Fabric | Rubic/Nimbus Fabric (Bolster/Insert) | ||
| Rear Centre Armrest | |||
| Rear Seat Armrest with Cup Holder | NA | ||
| Driver Seat Adjustment | |||
| Manual 6 Way Adjustment | NA | ||
INSTRUMENTATION | |||
| Instrument Cluster | |||
| Instrument Cluster with 7" Partial Color TFT Display | NA | Digital Cluster | |
LIGHTING | |||
| Split Rear Combination Lamps | |||
| Rear Combination with LED Signature | NA | NA | |
| Projector Headlamps | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Front Fog Lights | |||
| Yes with High-Gloss Finish Fog Light Surround | NA | ||
| DRLs (Daytime Running Lights) | |||
| LED DRLs & Light Guide | LED Daytime Running Lights | NA | |
| Cornering Lamps | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| LED Tail light | |||
| NA | NA | ||
| Interior Room Lamp | |||
| Front Cabin Light (Without Two Spot Lights) & Fade Out with Delay | Front Roof Lamp | ||
| ORVM Turn Indicators | |||
| Turn Indicator on ORVMs | NA | ||
| Head Light | |||
| Head Lamp Auto On-Off (Ambient and Tunnel Detection) | NA | NA | |
Comparison Comments